At Shamgar farewell, PM says amending role of Supreme Court is part of democracy

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Tuesday said adjusting the role of the Supreme Court is an inherent part of democracy and not a problem as long as the court maintains its independence.

Netanyahu made the remarks at a ceremony in Jerusalem as top government and state dignitaries paid their final respects to retired Supreme Court chief justice Meir Shamgar, who died over the weekend at 94.

Shamgar’s coffin lay in state at the Supreme Court in Jerusalem, a building whose construction he championed. Among those paying their respects were Supreme Court Chief Justice Ester Hayut, President Reuven Rivlin, Attorney General Avichai Mandelblit, and Blue and White party chief Benny Gantz.

Netanyahu, who has sought to curb the power of the court through legislation, including a proposed bill to override its rulings, spoke of tensions that exist between the executive, legislative and judicial branches of democracy.

“There is built-in tension between them. That tension is not a fault in democracy; it is the essence of democracy,” Netanyahu said. “As long as a simple principle, which I am careful of, is preserved: that the court must remain an independent authority.”

The prime minister and right-wing allies have backed legislation to nullify the High Court of Justice’s oversight of Knesset decisions, though they have had difficulty passing it in parliament. Critics say the legislation would unbalance Israel’s democracy and accuse Netanyahu of seeking the changes as part of a strategy to protect himself against prosecution in three corruption cases he is facing. Supporters say it is needed to stop what they claim is the court’s left-leaning stymieing of government action, even on matters of state security.

One of Shamgar’s career milestones was a 1995 ruling that anchored the court’s right to conduct judicial reviews of Knesset legislation and review whether laws conform with the quasi-constitutional Basic Law: Human Dignity and Liberty.

“Meir’s unique contribution to shaping the legal system is priceless,” Netanyahu said. “His firm and consistent belief in freedom of speech, individual liberties and tolerance is reflected in every judgment he made, as is his recognition of the supreme importance of state security.”

Rivlin and Hayut also spoke, with Rivlin recalling how Shamgar stood against excessive governmental power and Hayut saying his statesmanlike approach was an example of how public servants — including politicians — should do the right thing “even if it conflicts with one’s personal good.”

Rivlin said Shamgar spoke out “against public corruption” and “strengthened the protection of tolerance and freedom of expression.

“You were committed and devoted to human rights and the rule of law. You stood up for the importance of checks and balances between the branches [of government]. Balances whose purpose is to prevent the creation of excessive governmental power.”

Dan Shamgar, eulogized his father, saying “Dad fulfilled the Zionist vision that was so deeply ingrained in him throughout his life, out of a sense of mission and commitment to the nation, the land, society and the fundamental values he carried with him.”

Shamgar joined Israel’s top court in 1975 and eight years later took over as chief justice, a position he held for 12 years until 1995. He was to be buried later Tuesday afternoon at Givat Shaul cemetery in Jerusalem.

Source Article from

Related Posts
Mandatory Vaccines? The Supreme Court Said Yes! But Wait, There’s More…

May 18, 2020 By Spiro Skouras If there is one topic that even comes close Read more

Report on week two of Supreme Court Trial R v Roy Arthur Topham by Arthur Topham

EDITOR’S NOTE: Once again, please feel free to use whatever information is contained Read more

Report on first week of Supreme Court Trial R v Roy Arthur Topham by Arthur Topham

[EDITOR’S NOTE: Please feel free to use whatever information is contained in this Read more

Zuckerberg really must think we’re all ‘dumb f**ks’: Filling his ‘Supreme Court’ with like-minded liberals is just window dressing

Facebook's market capitalization is close to $700 billion and its primary businesses are publishing, advertising Read more

Hits: 53

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Leave a Reply

The maximum upload file size: 100 MB.
You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet, interactive, other.
Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded.


Powered by WordPress | Designed by: Premium WordPress Themes | Thanks to Themes Gallery, Bromoney and Wordpress Themes