Warning over Gary Speed and peril of a shackled Press

By
Michael Seamark and Daniel Martin

Last updated at 10:14 PM on 23rd December 2011

'Public interest': Gary Speed and his wife Louise

‘Public interest’: Gary Speed and his wife Louise

MPs and lawyers warned last night that legitimate journalistic investigations must not be stifled by high profile inquiries into the conduct of the Press.

The mysterious death of football boss Gary Speed has highlighted concerns facing newspapers currently under fierce examination by the Leveson Inquiry.

Since the Wales manager was found dead at his family home last month, little has been reported by the Press about why the popular 42-year-old apparently committed suicide.

And the Times newspaper, in a strongly-worded editorial comment published yesterday, used the case to demonstrate what it says is the need for newspapers to be able to undertake inquiries and publish matters of legitimate public interest.

The Times, MPs and lawyers all pointed to the fact that the internet has been awash with lurid, widely varying and totally unsubstantiated rumours about the circumstances surrounding the death of the married father of two.

‘Mr Speed has been smeared, not by the Press but in its absence,’ said the Times editorial.

Tory MP Philip Davies, who sits on the Commons culture, media and sport committee, agreed, saying: ‘The problem is that we are seeing a chilling effect on the Press and the rest of the respectable media, leaving a large field clear to the unregulated internet and social media so people can peddle lots of things that are not true.

‘These things are best covered in the respectable media so you get the truth, rather than unpleasant smears and lies.

Gary Speed untold story

Respects: A book of condolences in memory of Gary Speed is opened at the Football of Wales offices in Cardiff

Respects: A book of condolences in memory of Gary Speed is opened at the Football of Wales offices in Cardiff

‘There is a danger that the Press
feel they can’t report, and this chilling effect is counter- productive
for all concerned. We should be treasuring free speech in this country,
not having a situation where news organisations are scared to cover
stories.

‘It cannot be
helpful for the family to have all these lies peddled across the social
media. I would prefer it if these things were reported responsibly.’

Media
lawyer Mark Stephens was also concerned. He said: ‘When the Press is
restrained from legitimate reporting on privacy issues and other
matters, the unregulated world of the web comes into play.

‘There is then very little you can do about rumour and allegations which must be very troubling for his family, which can’t be scotched for the crimes that they are. There is a place for decent, responsible reporting. It also puts right all the false rumours.’

Mr Speed’s death is an unusual choice of topic for an editorial in the Times, but under the headline ‘Untold Story’ the paper said: ‘Gary Speed’s death raises matters of public interest that need to be reported.’

The Times added: ‘This story is being left alone. But the question has to be asked: is this reticence a good thing?’

Paying their respects: Fans at Leeds United's ground Elland Road show their grief at former player Gary Speed's death

Paying their respects: Fans at Leeds United’s ground Elland Road show their grief at former player Gary Speed’s death

Tributes: Hundreds of tributes including photographs, shirts and bouquets of flowers have been left at the Elland Road ground

Tributes: Hundreds of tributes including photographs, shirts and bouquets of flowers have been left at the Elland Road ground

The newspaper described phone-hacking as a ‘disgrace’ that demanded an inquiry but it warned: ‘It is critical, too, that we do not live in a society in which rumour takes the place of reporting, and misinformation triumphs over truth.’

Celebrity PR man Max Clifford, who warned last week that tabloid editors are too scared to publish sensational stories about the private lives of celebrities because they fear a backlash from readers angered by Press behaviour exposed at the Leveson Inquiry, also supported the Times argument.

He said: ‘I know of three people whose reputations are being tarnished and damaged by false stories and allegations, all of which would have been clarified if people had come out with their exclusive stories.

‘We all want a free Press but the reality is that at the moment the Press is not free. We have got a shackled Press.’

Here’s what other readers have said. Why not add your thoughts,
or debate this issue live on our message boards.

The comments below have been moderated in advance.

So the Times is calling for them to publish details of Gary Speed’s death as ‘it is in the public interest’. It is not in the public interest to publish this. As far as I am concerned It is a tragedy that Gary took his own life and the case and speculation is closed. His family know the truth and that is the way it should be. Let Gary Rest in Peace and his family grieve in peace.

It’s a private matter, leave the family alone to grieve in peace

The death of Gary Speed or similar should never be the job of the press to speculate, but the Police and Coroner yes!

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

Views: 0

You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress | Designed by: Premium WordPress Themes | Thanks to Themes Gallery, Bromoney and Wordpress Themes