- Eurasian jays outperform 7-year-olds in logic tests
- Birds do better than humans in two out of three tests
By
Fiona Macrae
16:05 EST, 25 July 2012
|
18:50 EST, 25 July 2012
In two of the three tests, the birds ¿ Eurasian jays ¿ did just as well as the seven-year-old children
IT’S a suggestion that will give pause for thought to even the proudest of parents.
For no matter how bright they believe their son or daughter is, until the age of seven, children are, at least in some respects, no brainier than birds.
In simple experiments, birds did just as well as children up until the age of seven.
Researchers pitted birds against boys and girls using tests inspired by the Aesop’s fable in which a thirsty crow is able to drink from a pitcher after using pebbles to raise the water level to within its reach.
In two of the three tests at Cambridge University, the birds – Eurasian jays – did just as well as the seven-year-old children.
After this, the human mind proved superior to the bird brain.
The experiments built on earlier work in which jays quickly learned that adding stones to a cylinder half-filled with water would bring a tasty treat floating on the surface within reach of their beaks.
In a second task the jays – colourful members of the crow family and about the same size as jackdaws – realised it was better to use pebbles, which sink, than corks, which float.
When Cambridgeshire children, aged four to ten, were set similar tasks, they did as well as the jays on the first, up to the age of seven.
Brainy boy? Up until the age of seven, children are, at least in some respects, be no brainier than birds
From the age of eight, the pupils
learned more quickly than the birds. The pattern was similar with the
second task – except four-year-old children did worse than the jays.
However, a third, more complex, task separated the youngsters from the birds.
It again involved dropping objects
into water to raise its level. But this time, a U-shaped tube was used,
with the join at its bottom hidden, giving the impression it was two
separate tubes.
It meant dropping a stone into one ‘tube’ led to the water rising in the ‘other’ – a counter-intuitive result.
This appeared to confuse the birds.
However, the children did as well as before, the journal PLoS ONE
reports. The researchers said this shows children are better at putting
preconceptions aside.
Lucy Cheke, a PhD student, said: ‘It
is a child’s job to learn about the world. They can’t do that if they’re
limited by a preconceived idea about what is or is not possible.
‘For a child, if it works, it works.
The birds, however, found it much harder to learn what was happening
because they were put off by the fact it shouldn’t be happening.’
-
Dark Knight gunman ‘forced to wear a face guard in prison… -
Kicked out for a racist tweet: Greek triple jumper is banned… -
Locked in combat: Mother lion takes on deadly crocodile to… -
‘It was terrifying… he told me he knew where to… -
The NYPD blues: Ex-cop chronicles boredom, depression and… -
Family of woman, 23, who fell to her death sliding down a… -
Drugs, alcohol and underage sex: The shocking scene that… -
Man living in ‘terror’ as his home is overrun by venomous… -
Bollywood star outrages India by agreeing to pose naked in… -
One giant plunge for mankind: Skydiver Fearless Felix leaps… -
Breathtaking force: World’s most powerful dam opens in China… -
‘I heard Indian people eat with their hands still’: Oprah…
Share this article:
Here’s what other readers have said. Why not add your thoughts,
or debate this issue live on our message boards.
The comments below have not been moderated.
-
Newest -
Oldest -
Best rated -
Worst rated
I am amazed by my 5 year old every day. Don’t know much about birds though.
Report abuse
Thank your friends at big pharma and the chemical industries for this. Kids will only keep getting dummer thanks to their brains being turned to mush by the endless toxic vaccines and tap water full of neurotoxic chemicals.
Report abuse
People who shares their lives with bird companions already know how smart their little ‘fids’ (‘kids with feathers’) are! 😀
Report abuse
As people we are supposed to be caretakers of the earth, all these tests just prove that animals are the children.
Report abuse
This exact research was on a TV show weeks ago. Has the world run out of news DM?
Report abuse
Merryjoy91, I sincerely hope that you are not a teacher responsible for teaching children to read, the article does say in “logic tests”; art is not mentioned.
No doubt the cleverest birds were migratory ones.
Report abuse
She was a brilliant little artist, I highly doubt a bird could do that.
– merryjoy91, Pembrokeshire uk, 25/7/2012 23:41…..yeah, but could she fly at 3 months?
Report abuse
I’m not a bit surprised really.
Report abuse
Erm, a 7 year old drew some fantastic pictures today, even one for me and a friend to take home. She was a brilliant little artist, I highly doubt a bird could do that.
Report abuse
The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.