Soldier who killed his landlady cleared of murder because he was suffering from post-traumatic stress after serving in Afghanistan

By
Eddie Wrenn

09:00 EST, 3 April 2012

|

09:38 EST, 3 April 2012


Killed: Farm owner Judith Garnett was shot to death in the attic of her Leeds home by ex-soldier Aarron Wilkinson

Killed: Farm owner Judith Garnett was shot to death in the attic of her Leeds home by ex-soldier Aarron Wilkinson

A former soldier suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder has been cleared today of murdering his landlady.

Aaron Wilkinson, 24, of Alma Street, Woodlesford, Leeds, was found not guilty of murdering 52-year-old Judith Garnett by shooting her in the chest and head.

Wilkinson, who was also diagnosed with a form of Asperger’s Syndrome, told Bradford Crown Court he was not in control of his actions when he shot Mrs Garnett.

He has admitted manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility.

The jury took around three hours to reach the not-guilty verdict after the two-week trial.

The trial heard that Wilkinson joined the Territorial Army at 19 and went on a six-month tour of duty of Afghanistan in 2009.

Following his return, he was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder by an army doctor and has since also been found to suffer from Asperger’s Syndrome, or a similar condition.

He was later assessed by psychiatrists who diagnosed him with the more serious post-traumatic stress disorder.

Wilkinson had worked for Mrs Garnett on her game farm for around 10 years and moved into her attic room as a lodger in July 2010 after an argument with his mother. He described Mrs Garnett as being like a ‘second mother’ to him.

On the day of the shooting, Mrs Garnett returned home and shouted at him for not letting her dogs out during the day as she had requested, calling him ‘thick’ and a ‘cruel bastard’.

Wilkinson said Mrs Garnett threw his gun up through the hatch into his attic bedroom and told him to ‘pack his bags’.

When Mrs Garnett returned to the attic room, Wilkinson fired three shots at her.

The first shot hit Mrs Garnett in the chest, the second grazed the side of her face and the third was fired from close range into her head.

War veteran Aaron Wilkinson said the events played out like a movie and how he 'wasn't in full control'

War veteran Aaron Wilkinson said the events played out like a movie and how he ‘wasn’t in full control’

Wilkinson said he could not explain why he shot Mrs Garnett and said it was as though he was in a ‘trance’.

Giving evidence, he said: ‘All of a sudden, something came over me, I don’t know what, I can’t explain that, all I just remember seeing is me lunging over to the other bed and I just watched myself load the gun and fire.

‘It just sort of happened, I don’t know what came over me.’

The defendant added: ‘It sort of just went black and white and hazy at times. It was like I just turned into a mad man.’

He continued: ‘I felt like somebody I’m not.’

Wilkinson said he did not feel in control of himself at the time and would not have killed Mrs Garnett if he had been.

He said he remembered the events as though he were watching them in a movie or on television.

‘It was like a TV screen, I’ve seen what was happening but I wasn’t in full control,’ he said.

Wilkinson told the jury he realised what he had done immediately after firing the third shot.

‘Straight away I saw what had happened and realised that I’d done a terrible wrong and phoned the police straight away,’ he said.

The trial heard that Wilkinson’s mother told him she was not his mother any more and his application to join the regular Army had been turned down.

A soldier in Afghanistan: Aaron Wilkinson was diagnosed with PTSD after returning from a tour with the Territorial Army (file picture)

A soldier in Afghanistan: Aaron Wilkinson was diagnosed with PTSD after returning from a tour with the Territorial Army (file picture)

He was finding it hard to adapt to civilian life and was struggling to motivate himself.

Psychiatrists told the court that Wilkinson’s medical conditions meant he would have found the rejection by Mrs Garnett when she told him to move out ‘catastrophic’.

The court heard that his Asperger’s Syndrome meant he would have been less able to cope with the symptoms of his post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

The combination of the two conditions led to a ‘real risk of a violent explosion’ and an inability to exercise self-control when he felt himself to be under threat by Mrs Garnett, the court was told.

Summing up the case, Mr Justice Kenneth Parker said the ‘unpredictable, inexplicable, uncontrolled and out-of-character explosive act of violence’ could be explained by Wilkinson’s mental conditions, which were ‘likely to substantially impair his ability to exercise self-control’.

Wilkinson’s sentencing was adjourned for at least two months for further psychiatric assessments to take place to decide on the danger posed by the defendant.

Paul Greaney QC, defending, said this would benefit Wilkinson by deciding what treatment he would receive and would also benefit the public by obtaining a greater understanding of his risk and how it should be managed in the future.

Mr Justice Kenneth Parker thanked the family of Mrs Garnett for their dignity.

‘This has been a very difficult and, in many ways, distressing, if not harrowing, trial,’ he said.

‘This must have been the most appalling experience for you and I have the deepest admiration for the dignity with which you have sat in court and listened to the evidence.’

The judge added: ‘I thank you very much for your impeccable behaviour during the course of this trial.’

Speaking outside the court after the verdict, Detective Chief Inspector Chris Walker, of West Yorkshire Police, said: ‘No one could have predicted the dreadful events when a young man Judith Garnett had supported for many years turned on her in such a violent and horrific way.’

He said the family were disappointed with the verdict but accepted it and praised them for the ‘dignity and restraint’ they had shown throughout the trial.

Reading a statement from the family, Mr Walker said: ‘(Judith Garnett) took in Aaron Wilkinson when he was homeless, gave him a roof over his head, employment and treated him like part of the family.

‘She was a kind, generous woman and a remarkable woman, truly admired by many and an inspiration to those who knew her.

‘We all feel a huge gap in our lives that can never be replaced.’

Here’s what other readers have said. Why not add your thoughts,
or debate this issue live on our message boards.

The comments below have been moderated in advance.

How the heck can you be found “not guilty” of shooting a person dead. I can’t believe what I’m reading. How much more evidence does the system need!!!!

In my world he’d just get 25yrs for having the gun, and then 25yrs for the killing to run CONSECUTIVELY
This sort of thing did’nt happen in the late 40s 50s when the MEN came home after 5yrs of war.

So this is how you treat your second mum? RIP Judith, you didn’t deserve to die in this way…. condolences to your family

Simply unbelievable!

British justice is now a sad betrayal of all it once stood for when a murderer can walk free.

OMG! I cant belive it . what will happen next time ? OMG!

-Steve Birmingham – have you been trained in in an army or have seen your your friends die because your mates died? I do not condone his actions, but perhaps some sympathy coulid be extended! Ever considered the blithering idiots over the past 14 years may have something to do with blame..

oh ,,,, so thats ok then is it ,,,,,,,,,,, god give me strength !!!!! poor lady .

Rest in peace xx
This is a sad story, his illnesses are severe and he can’t help himself. A real shame.
He does I think need to be sectioned and hospitalised for a few years for sure. I do not blame him. The affects of war are awful 🙁

Disgusting and shameful.
Clearly its OK to kill someone, even when you aren’t on ‘active duty’ as a soldier.

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress | Designed by: Premium WordPress Themes | Thanks to Themes Gallery, Bromoney and Wordpress Themes